In short
Almost every open call is judged in three stages. First, someone checks eligibility and completeness; work is not yet looked at. Then jurors make a fast first pass, often a few seconds per application, mostly on the first image. Finally they discuss the shortlist: texts, budgets, fit with the brief and how the selected works sit together. Research on peer review shows experts often disagree on strong applications, so a rejection is frequent and not always meaningful.
- —One formal mistake can end an application before anyone sees the work.
- —The first image and the first sentence carry the first pass. Make both clear and on-brief.
- —If the jury is one invited expert, ten minutes on their past shows can save you a fee.
- —Each kind of selector is afraid of something. A good application answers that fear before it is asked.
- Applications per place (median)
- 363 for 8.5
- 62 calls in the CallOpen archive that published both numbers (about 1 in 30).
- Results that name the jury
- 26%
- Of past calls whose results we found published (28 October 2026).
- Reviewer agreement on strong grants
- about zero
- Pier et al., PNAS 2018: 43 reviewers, 25 funded NIH applications.
- Rijksakademie, 2027 intake
- 23 of 2,258
- About 1%. Applicants from 122 countries.
How we counted: The process described here comes from funders’ published guidance (Pollock-Krasner Foundation, Arts Council England, Canada Council), research on expert judgement, and practitioners’ accounts of large digital selections. Accounts of how long a first look takes are practitioners’ descriptions, not measurements, so treat them as a rough guide.
Who sits at the table
“The jury” can mean very different things. One invited expert is common in US juried shows: a curator or artist picks the works and the prizes, so the result depends heavily on one person’s taste. A panel of curators or artists is typical for prizes and residencies. Public funders usually have programme staff and external peer assessors score applications against published criteria. Institution staff run selection themselves at many residencies and exhibition calls. Nominators propose candidates for some large prizes that take no applications at all.
This tells you who you are writing for. One expert: study them. A council with criteria: answer the criteria. Nominations: work on your network.
One invited expert is the most predictable case. A realist painter will probably lean towards figurative work with high finish; a curator known for technology projects will probably lean the other way. That is a probability, not a rule, but probability is what we work with. Before paying a fee for a show with one juror, spend ten minutes on their biography and past exhibitions.
The three stages
1. The admin check. A staff member or a system checks eligibility: country, age, completeness, file formats, every required part. Nobody looks at the work yet. The Pollock-Krasner Foundation states that applications with incomplete or incorrect information are disqualified automatically, and you can only reapply after 24 months. One formal mistake there costs two years.
2. The first pass. Jurors go through every eligible application quickly and sort them into no, maybe and yes. We found no published measurements for art selections, but people who run large digital selections describe a first look of about five seconds per application, then 10–15 seconds to decide. That matches research on first impressions: in Lindgaard and colleagues’ 2006 study, judgements of a web page after 50 milliseconds closely matched judgements made with more time.
3. Discussion. The yes and maybe groups are looked at in depth: all images, the texts, the budgets. Here details decide: fit with the theme, feasibility, and balance across media, places and generations. Some strong applications drop out simply because a similar work has already been chosen.
A juror’s three days
A composite example based on published descriptions of the process, not one real person or programme. A curator agrees to select a group show for a small non-profit. 640 applications arrive, five images each, shown as a grid of thumbnails.
Evening one: the first pass. She removes what clearly does not fit: off-theme work, technically poor photos, applications where it is unclear what is shown. A few seconds each, mostly the first image. She barely reads. About 120 maybes and 30 yeses remain.
Day two: she opens those 150 properly, reads the texts and imagines the works together. Out go applications where a strong first image is not supported by the rest, and ones where the text promises one thing and the images show another.
Day three: she builds a show of 25–30 works. Now the question is the combination: not three similar abstractions but one, not only painting, not only local artists.
What to do with this: each stage has its own filter. Clarity and a strong first image for the first. A coherent series and text that matches the images for the second. The third you hardly control.
Experts disagree more than you think
In a study by Pier and colleagues (PNAS, 2018), 43 reviewers independently scored 25 real NIH grant applications, all of which had in fact been funded. Agreement between reviewers was practically zero: scores for the same application from different reviewers differed more than scores for different applications.
This does not prove selection is arbitrary. It shows that among strong applications, much of the difference comes from who is scoring. There is no reason to think art juries agree more than scientists, whose criteria are more formal.
Order matters too. Wändi Bruine de Bruin (Acta Psychologica, 2005) found that later performers in Eurovision and figure skating championships got systematically higher scores. You rarely control the order in which applications are seen. You do control the order inside your own: the first image and the first sentence.
What each kind of selector is afraid of
It helps to think about what the jury fears, not only what it looks for.
- A grant funder fears the project will not happen. They must report on the money. Plans, budgets, schedules and proof that you have done similar work matter.
- A residency fears you will not fit in. You will live next to the team and other residents for months. Show that you understand the place and its conditions.
- An exhibition curator fears the work will look worse than in the photo, or cannot be shipped, installed or insured. Give dimensions, weight and installation needs.
- A public-art commissioner fears missed deadlines, overspending and scandal. Experience, insurance and engineering detail answer that.
- Everyone fears untruth. A generic text that could describe any artist raises suspicion, especially now that such texts are easy to generate. Specific detail is the best answer.
Build the application for the 300th look of the day
Imagine yours is the 300th application of the day. The juror is tired and looking for a reason to decide. Help them.
- Pass the admin check: number of images, size, format, file names, word limits, attachments. Check twice.
- First image: your strongest complete work, closest to the brief. Not a detail, not an installation view.
- First sentence: what you make. Not a philosopher’s quote, not your childhood.
- Text structure follows the criteria. If they are quality, development and feasibility, give three recognisable blocks in that order.
- One body of work, not a greatest-hits collection.
- Nothing extra. If the eighth, ninth and tenth images are weaker, you do not have to send them.
- Check how each image reads as a thumbnail. Work that only reads large loses in the first pass.
- In an anonymous call, remove your name from files, metadata and text.
| Mistake | What it can cost | How to avoid it |
|---|---|---|
| Wrong file size or format | Disqualification or a distorted image | Keep a separate export for each programme |
| Text or watermark on the image | Some programmes ban it outright | Keep clean versions of your files |
| Word or character limit exceeded | Text cut off, or rejection | Count characters with spaces when the limit is in characters |
| A detail instead of the whole work | The juror cannot tell what it is | Details only after the whole view, and only if allowed |
| Your name in an anonymous call | Disqualification | Check file metadata and the text |
| A missing part (budget, CV, reference) | Rejected before anyone looks | Use a completeness checklist |
| Submitting in the last hour | Technical failure | Leave at least a day of margin |
Template
Read the call through the jury’s eyes
Ten minutes before you start an application. It tells you who you are writing for and what they will check first.
READ THE CALL LIKE A JUROR — [call name] WHO JUDGES [ ] The jury is named: [names] [ ] One person / a panel / staff / peer assessors / nominators [ ] For one invited expert: I looked at their past shows and texts. My work is within / outside their interests. WHAT THEY CHECK [ ] Assessment criteria copied word for word: 1) ____ 2) ____ 3) ____ [ ] If no criteria are published, what the organiser wants at the end: ____ [ ] Last cycle: ____ applications for ____ places ADMIN CHECK (twice) [ ] Number of images ____, size ____, format ____, file names ____ [ ] Word/character limits: ____ (unit: words / characters with spaces) [ ] All parts: portfolio / statement / proposal / budget / CV / references / video [ ] Anonymous call? Name removed from files, metadata and text [ ] Submitting at least a day before the deadline FIRST PASS [ ] First image: my strongest complete work, closest to the brief [ ] Every image reads as a thumbnail [ ] First sentence says what I make DISCUSSION [ ] Text follows the criteria, in their order [ ] What the text promises is visible in the images [ ] I have answered what this selector is afraid of: ____